Am I the scoundrel for prohibiting the presence of spirits during the festivities of Christmas?

My husband’s family is rather partial to the pleasures of imbibing, and it is not uncommon for their holiday gatherings to feature a generous assortment of wines and libations. I, on the other hand, harbour a vehement aversion to the consumption of alcohol, a sentiment rooted in the unfortunate experience of having been raised under the shadow of a father plagued by intemperance. I firmly believe that it is a mark of juvenile sensibilities to rely upon such indulgences for the purposes of merriment.

As it so happens, this year the responsibility of hosting the Christmas celebrations has fallen to me, and I resolved to seize the opportunity to impose a stringent proscription on alcoholic beverages within the confines of my abode. Given the advancing years of our party, I deemed it high time for a more mature approach to our festivities.

Upon receiving an inquiry from my husband’s sister regarding what she might contribute to our gathering, I informed her of my prohibition on alcohol, as she had expressed an interest in preparing a seasonal concoction of the inebriating variety. Though she offered little response at the time, it appears she subsequently shared the news with the remainder of the family, who proceeded to inundate me with incredulous letters questioning the veracity of my edict and branding it as tiresome.

To my dismay, it has come to my attention that my husband’s sister has elected to host an alternative soiree, to which the majority of our relations have opted to attend, rather than endure a single day of sobriety. I find myself deeply affronted by this flagrant display of disrespect.

My husband, in his efforts to broker peace, has suggested that we abandon our own celebration and join the gathering at his sister’s home, but I remain resolute in my refusal to attend such an impertinent affair.

He now harbours resentment towards me for obliging him to remain at home and share Christmas in my company, when it was my turn to host and dictate the terms of our engagement. They might have tolerated my decision for one year, and yet I am left to wonder: Am I the scoundrel in this matter?

further remarks and discourse follows

With all due respect, you seem to be the scoundrel in this situation. While I comprehend the origins of your sentiments, it is imperative that you also endeavour to appreciate the perspectives of others. This occasion is neither a celebration of your nuptials nor the anniversary of your birth; rather, it is an event intended to unite loved ones in harmony and happiness. Throughout the year, many individuals toil diligently and are afforded only infrequent opportunities to convene with their families. When such gatherings do transpire, it is natural for them to seek relaxation and revelry. Admittedly, the presence of alcohol may be an integral component of these festivities for some. However, it behooves one to discern that there exists a moderate and acceptable middle ground, one that permits the enjoyment of a few modest beverages without descending into the depths of inebriated chaos.

It appears that you may be inadvertently imposing your own distressing experiences upon others. Regrettably, this renders you the scoundrel in this instance. I would recommend seeking counsel or engaging in personal reflection to address these underlying concerns.